Daryl Dixon Highlights The Walking Dead's Most Complicated Character
The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon Season 2 is the latest addition to the expanding world of The Walking Dead. In the previous season, the franchise captivated audiences with the inclusion of a part of the post-apocalyptic world that has yet to be explored. In the finale of the first season, Daryl is faced with the dilemma of staying with his new allies or journeying back to the United States to be with his long-running friends. Though he chose to temporarily remain with the French people who need his protection and expertise, this doesn't mean his old life remains in the past.
In the first episode of Season 2, The Book of Carol, the narrative mainly focuses on his oldest and dearest friend, Carol, who goes on a mission to find out what happened to Daryl in order to bring him back home. This was necessary to set a foundation for realistically incorporating this long-running character. However, this storyline begins with Carol telling a monumental lie to a kind stranger. Despite the controversy over Carol's decisions, this first episode of Daryl Dixon Season 2 emphasizes why she is the most complicated character ever featured in the franchise.
Carol's Journey Begins With a Major Deceit
In Daryl Dixon Season 2, Episode 1, "La Gentillesse des Estrangers," the narrative follows both Daryl and Carol's points of view. However, the episode dominantly focuses on Carol picking up where the previous season left off, outlining how she ends up finding passage to France. After threatening and harming men in Maine to find out Daryl's possible location, the long-time friend goes on a journey to an abandoned shipyard where Daryl likely took off. When she sees a plane flying overhead and crashes her car while distracted, Carol sneaks into a secluded compound and makes the sole occupant believe she requires help.
At this point, Daryl Dixon Season 2 ups the emotional stakes by revealing the lone occupant, Ash Patel, is living in solitude because he's built a shrine for his deceased son. While staying with Ash, Carol has flashbacks of losing her daughter, Sophia, suggesting she may develop an emotional connection with the friendly stranger. During a dinner with Ash, she brings up Sophia. However, to the shock of the audience, she lies about her daughter, telling Ash that Sophia went on a trip to France right before the outbreak and is holding on to hope that her child is still alive.
This seems like a bad decision when Ash gets angry, and Carol goes off on foot. Despite this, Ash quickly finds her and decides to prepare his small aircraft to take her to France. Though Ash believes he's going on a mission to find her long-lost son, Carol and the audience are faced with the reality that she lied in order to find Daryl. This seems like a necessary deceit so that Carol can find Daryl and reunite with him for an upcoming epic storyline. Even with this lie being required to somehow get this character to Europe, it seems like a particularly horrendous and dishonest beginning to a storyline.
This Is Consistent With Previous Characterization
There's no denying that this deceit is a major indicator of Carol's negative attributes. On the other hand, there are various instances in which this character has made difficult decisions that portray her as morally gray. In The Walking Dead, she is one of the people who often doesn't hesitate to commit acts of violence against the living to protect those she loves. This is presented in plot points such as her attacking Terminus to save her people, killing Lizzie to protect baby Judith, and taking up arms again to defend the Kingdom against threats such as the Whisperers. Though this is a key reason Carol has struggled so much with her identity as a survivor in the post-apocalyptic world, it is also why she is a fan-favorite character in The Walking Dead universe.
In the new season of this spin-off, Daryl Dixon highlights Carol's evolution by perfectly capturing her characterization. She has often played on others underestimating her to get them to trust her, such as acting like an innocent victim when she enters Ash's compound. She also utilizes this perception of her when she utilizes the memory of her daughter to trick him into using his plane to take her to France. While it's obvious she can handle herself, proven by her and Ash taking on a horde of walkers, the trauma of having a "missing child" gets Carol what she wants most: transportation to help find Daryl. This is consistent with Carol's previous characterization, which isn't just about her making difficult decisions to protect her loved ones but about her going through extraordinary and controversial measures to ensure the safety of people important to her.
Ash and Carol Share a Common Trauma
The common trauma Ash and Carol share cannot be ignored when going into this Daryl Dixon Season 2 storyline. In this first episode, the audience is moved by the loss of Ash's son, Avi, who died after the apocalypse began. This grieving father blames himself for not paying close enough attention to his young child, which he feels caused the demise. This is not dissimilar to Carol losing her daughter in the second season of The Walking Dead. Though it seems as though Carol uses this trauma to manipulate Ash, the scenario is more complicated than that.
The short-lived storyline of Sophia in The Walking Dead is a surprisingly important aspect of this season of Daryl Dixon. Sophia is a crucial part of Carol's characterization, but she's never been more important post-death than in this spin-off installment. In Season 2 of The Walking Dead, Carol's focus is protecting her young child following the demise of her abusive husband, Ed. When Sophia disappears into the woods while being chased by a couple of walkers, she turns up several days later as one of the undead. Carol not only blames herself for this demise but dedicates herself to protecting others she cares about, to try to prevent the pain she endured after losing her child.
Over a decade later, this trauma continues to dictate Carol's decisions. When she learns of Ash's loss, she uses Sophia to manipulate Ash into helping her get to Europe. This is an obvious deception, but one that is not as devious as it seems. Considering how secluded and mournful Ash is years after the demise of his son, it's likely Carol saw herself in the kind stranger. By convincing Ash to take her on an excursion, even under the guise of false pretenses, Carol is removing him from his consuming guilt and giving him a meaningful mission. Though it isn't for the purposes Ash believes, this morally gray but well-intentioned character is giving this recluse an opportunity to experience the world outside his self-induced prison.
This Can Play Into an Important Daryl Dixon Plot
Carol deceiving Ash for her own gain doesn't necessarily make her character unlikable but highlights why she has continued to captivate audiences since the beginning of her evolution in The Walking Dead Season 3. As the franchise has continued, the need for and interest in morally gray characters has become a focal point. In a dangerous and controversial world, Carol is the pinnacle of what makes a fascinating and lovable character. Despite Carol making these questionable decisions for the good of beloved characters, these complicated moral dilemmas result in the most captivating storylines in the franchise.
Among the many fascinating inclusions that will be featured in Daryl Dixon, the premise that places Carol and Ash in France is certainly going to continue audience interest in the spin-off. The Walking Dead has focused on the importance of children on and off throughout its many years, but this fresh addition is highlighting it in a unique way. Between the storyline of Laurent in France and using the trauma of losing a child during the apocalypse, which is a common occurrence in this world, Daryl Dixon emphasizes why the youth of this post-apocalyptic world influences the adult characters.
The promise of The Walking Dead's spin-offs to rejuvenate the horror franchise has not disappointed so far. Daryl Dixon: The Book of Carol is continuing the trend of revolutionizing the series, despite it recycling an original character to continue the plotline. Between focusing on previous trauma and new, complex characters, the series emphasizes why the treacherous and elaborate storyline endlessly entertains dedicated and new fans.